I have been spending my afternoons of late contemplating the curious machinery of the American mind, which is a contraption of such marvelous and contradictory gears that it would make a Swiss watchmaker take to his bed with a permanent headache. We are a people of high ideals and low thresholds for discomfort, a nation that keeps a Bible on the nightstand and a ledger under the pillow, and we manage to balance the two without ever letting the right hand know what the left is embezzling.
It is a peculiar thing, this business of being a civilized human being in a century that seems determined to prove that civilization is merely a thin coat of varnish applied to a very rough and splintery piece of timber. We talk of progress as if it were a train that only travels in one direction, forgetting that a train can just as easily derail into a swamp as it can pull into a station of Enlightenment.
The Great American Press—that noble engine of enlightenment that operates with all the precision of a clock and about as much soul as a patent-medicine advertisement—is currently engaged in a spectacular performance of Selective Blindness. It is a sort of optical infirmity that would baffle a Cairo eye-doctor, yet it is practiced with such consistency that one begins to wonder if it is taught in the universities right alongside grammar and geography.
We find ourselves in a season where the Gospel of the Cable-Gram has replaced the Sermon on the Mount. In the old days, a man had to look his enemy in the eye before he dispatched him to the Great Beyond, but we have improved upon that primitive arrangement. Now, we have the Passive Voice, which is the greatest labor-saving device since the cotton gin and twice as efficient at cleaning up a mess.
In the hands of a skilled journalist, a military strike is not something a man does to another man; it is something that simply happens, like a change in the weather or a sudden onset of the croup. When a rain of iron falls upon a village halfway across the world, the headlines do not speak of triggers or intent. They speak of Kinetic Activity and Casualties Reported, as if the shells were launched by Providence itself.
It is a beautiful system of verbal gymnastics. If a stray cat is rescued from a well in Cincinnati, we are treated to four columns of prose and a portrait of the cat’s grieving mother. But when the business of war becomes inconvenient to the national narrative, our editors develop a fit of modesty so profound they can hardly bring themselves to mention the butcher’s bill above a whisper.
They have a great reverence for the Official Spokesman, a man in a polished uniform who stands at a podium and dispenses Truth—triple-distilled and bottled at the source. If the Spokesman says the hospital was actually a nest of vipers, the Press prints it as Holy Writ. If a thousand mothers on the ground scream that it was merely a hospital, the Press calls it unverified claims, which is a polite way of saying the witnesses lack the proper credentials to be dead.
This is the Architecture of Omission, a vast, shimmering grid of illumination and shadow. The light is directed with the surgical precision of a stagehand, and the darkness is curated with the deliberate intent of an architect. We are fed a diet of Strategic Interests and Tactical Successes, while the human heart of the matter is left to rot in the sun like a forgotten peach.
There is a Fear of the Unpleasant Label that haunts the newsrooms of our great cities. In this land of the free, a journalist may criticize the President, the Clergy, and the Laws of Gravitation with impunity. But let him cast a critical eye toward the military adventures of a favored ally, and he shall find himself fitted with a Label before the ink is dry on his copy.
The editor, being a man who enjoys his lunch and his salary, decides that perhaps a story about a Diplomatic Process is much safer than a story about a Demolished Neighborhood. It is a sensible trade, from a certain point of view. A conscience is a heavy thing to carry around, and it rarely pays dividends at the end of the fiscal year.
We must also consider the Geography of the Heart. It is a well-known fact of American geography that a drop of blood spilled in a Friendly country is a tragedy of Shakespearean proportions, while a river of blood in a Foreign land is merely a statistic, like the price of pork bellies or the annual rainfall in the Sahara.
We are told that these matters are Complicated. That is the favorite word of the man who does not wish to explain himself. It is a linguistic shroud used to smother moral clarity. It’s complicated, says the editor, as he buries the report on page twenty-four, right next to the advertisement for a reliable corn-cure.
The truth is treated as a High-Yield Liability—an Asset that is too volatile to be liquidated into the public consciousness without being heavily diluted by the waters of Context. We prefer our reality sanitized, packaged, and delivered with a bow, so that we may consume it without losing our appetite for dinner.
The Syntax of Evasion is our national language. We do not witness; we observe. We do not kill; we neutralize. We do not suffer; we experience collateral impact. It is a marvelous way to live, provided you can keep the mirrors in your house covered so you don’t have to look at the person who is paying for the performance.
The American public is kept in a state of blissful ignorance, safe in the knowledge that our side is always right, their side is always wrong, and the bombs we pay for always have the good manners to only hit the Bad Guys. It is a grand performance, a circus of the intellect where the lions are made of straw and the tightrope is an inch off the ground.
And the best part of this spectacular show is that we don’t even have to pay admission at the gate. We pay for it with our conscience instead—and at current market rates, that’s a bargain. We trade our capacity for outrage for a comfortable seat in the gallery, and we applaud the silence as if it were a symphony.
I have lived long enough to know that a lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its boots, but in the modern age, the truth isn’t even allowed to have boots. It is kept barefoot and locked in the cellar, while the lie is given a first-class ticket and a letter of introduction to the best families.
We are a nation of designers, and what we have designed is a way to look at the world without ever seeing it. We have built a Filtered Reality that protects us from the glare of our own reflections. It is a triumph of engineering, a masterpiece of the mundane, and a tragedy of the highest order.
The ledger of our awareness is carefully balanced to ensure that while the facts may be technically present, the truth remains entirely absent. We are experts at the Terminal Inventory, counting the things that do not matter so we can ignore the things that do. The headlines are full, but the soul is an empty cupboard.
So the Great Silence continues, muffled by the rustle of the morning paper and the hum of the television. We go about our business, secure in our curated indifference, while the world outside our window burns with a fire we helped to kindle. It is a grand, glittering, hollow spectacle, and we are its most devoted fans.